Why Do 10th Graders Read the Lottery by Shirley Jackson

"The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson is such a dandy, memorable tale. I'thousand certain there aren't many teachers who must be persuaded to teach this one. Nevertheless, the relevance to pandemic living is so stiff, I but had to add this story to our classics to keep.

If this is a story we already honey and one that probably won't disappear from the curriculum, what more than of an argument does it need? Well, nosotros said the aforementioned thing nigh To Kill a Mockingbird one time, and now there's a lot of talk about replacing it with Just Mercy. (Don't worry. Nosotros'll talk over that thought in some other post.)

"The Lottery" is a great story to remind u.s.a. of a couple of points when studying classic lit. Outset, we must make sure we requite equal weight to both the relevance and the writing. Second, we should embrace the idea of second studies.

Let's get-go with the second bespeak first. If your schoolhouse commune is anything similar every single district I've worked in, someone somewhere has compiled a list of which works are read at which form level. The thought behind the listing is to ensure against repeats. It makes sense. And so many books, so little time, correct? I've  seen many an incensed teacher rant most how the heart school stole the books the high school wanted to teach, equally if there is a finite number of texts suitable for student consumption.

While I completely empathise and, for the most part, support the thought of non repeating texts, I also feel that it's non the end of the world if nosotros do. In fact, studying a work a 2d fourth dimension can exist quite eye-opening for students. They suddenly run across their own growth as informed and skilled readers. Similar to the experience of watching Atomic number 26 Human for the umpteenth time, they'll notice things they didn't the first time around. It's the reason I truly practice not care if students have seen Baz Luhrman's Smashing Gatsby moving-picture show before nosotros read it. In fact, sometimes I like information technology when they have seen it. We take the plot out of the fashion and tin can concentrate on the million other ways to study the Great American Novel. The aforementioned is especially truthful for the genius of foreshadow and irony that is "The Lottery". Yes, it's deliciously fun to experience students reading works like "The Lottery", "The Most Dangerous Game", "The Necklace", and "Gift of the Magi" for the first time.  Ideally, even so, you should read a text 3 times to even begin a proper assay.

Okay, that terminal claim came from i of my graduate professors. In that location is merit to it, but in that location's not the time for it. The closest we might come is revisiting in high schoolhouse a piece students all the same remember from center school. They absolutely remember "The Lottery". They'll remember it into adulthood. Volition they know why they remember it, though? That's where the deep dive into analysis comes in. Let's find out why we remember. Again, with the plot out of the way, we can study the meg other glories of Shirley Jackson's creepy tale. I tin't say it plenty. Never shy away from a second study. If you lot practice, you lot will miss an excellent opportunity to create even stronger connections to literature.

Side annotation: And for crying out loud, end whining most the eye school teachers stealing your stuff. Rejoice that you have the opportunity to add something new and different to your curriculum. There are more stories, y'all know.

Dorsum to indicate one and the reminder to rest the study of relevance and writing. Most classic literature lends itself to this necessity. Some stories, notwithstanding, contain and so much juicy goodness that information technology's too easy to become lost in the reader reaction and the discussion and the can-you-imangines. We forget to study the writing, too. For "The Lottery", I advise focusing on the writing first. Jackson does such a splendid task of drawing on the reader's prior knowledge, we don't even recognize that she'southward been stringing united states along the whole time.

The story is like a mesmerizing magic trick, and the lesson is similar giving students a peek behind the drape. Think about it. What'south the first affair nosotros say when nosotros experience a really expert magic trick. Our jaws drop open. Nosotros gasp in delight and say, "How did you do that?" This is exactly the reaction your students volition take, and you task is to ride the momentum of curiosity. So you become back and allow students to option apart Jackson's word pick, foreshadowing, and cute sprinkles of irony and characterization. Y'all guide them through how Jackson uses the reader'due south prior cognition to lead them down the path she wants them to accept.

In one case the students are enjoying the denouement of "knowing" the fox, you pull out your relevancy lesson. If yous've taught this text before, you know at that place are countless cultural lessons to pull from this story.

• Freedom vs. Safe
• Permission vs. Consent
• Luck vs. Fate
• Traditions vs. Culture
• Patriarchal Societies
• Gender Roles
• Generational Views

I'one thousand sure y'all can remember of more. With the state of the world right now, the relevancy is renewed. Every single one of these issues are so in the forefront right at present, students have almost likely heard the real life implications of at least i. Near take probably already discussed them with families, friends, or on social media. Can you imagine pairing "The Lottery" with recent existent life stories highlighting the divisiveness of generational viewpoints or the question of what society will surrender to feel safe fifty-fifty with a lack of concrete bear witness that those measures really create safety. Brand sure to remind students that this piece was written over seventy years ago in 1948. What if you could inquiry the very same issues we've been screaming about in 2020 but from a 1948 newspaper?

This commodity from AmericanLiterature.com offers interesting insight into how Jackson's story was received when it was first published in New Yorker magazine. In short, people didn't like information technology. Readers cancelled their subscriptions. They said it was insulting, interpreting information technology in a manner she might not have even meant for it to exist interpreted. Her own parents were disappointed that she'd written it. Imagine that. How is that situation much different from the misinterpretation and misunderstanding leading to anger and causing rifts between family members that we have going on in the earth today?

One of the most important reasons to proceed kids reading classics is to offer hope. Yes, even in Jackson's seemingly hopeless story, y'all can discover promise if you look for information technology. Later all, "some places have already quit lotteries". But the real hope comes from the thought that society has weathered storms before. Yeah, it seems we take to keep relearning the aforementioned lessons, just remembering our history teaches usa that we can, indeed, relearn them. We must.

This pandemic and subsequent distance learning has forced educators to rethink the mode we teach. One exciting part of that is the run a risk to rethink new real life connections to texts. "The Lottery" already has it's place in our classrooms. How can it at present have an even more relevant place in our understanding of society?

I challenge you to study "The Lottery" in your classroom this year, whether it'due south for the offset time or a repeat. Students have a different view of the globe than they did even half-dozen months ago. They volition bring a new reader's brain to the text and volition learn new lessons from it. It's worth a look or 2 or three. I promise. (I'yard not just trying to win points with my sometime professor.)

I know many of you read "The Lottery" in your classrooms. We'd love for you to share your all-time ideas for creating connections with this story. Delight, go out your ideas in the comments section below.

Be well. Read well. Live well.

myerstroses1992.blogspot.com

Source: https://keepingclassics.com/the-lottery-lesson/

Share this post